Disclosure: I may earn a commission if you buy through links on this site, at no extra cost to you. Right now these are plain retailer links. Full disclosure
Stage pianos head-to-head: MODX M8 vs FP-90X vs PX-S3100 vs P-125
Four 88-key boards that show up on gig lists, from a full performance synth to a slim battery-powered piano. Specs below come from Yamaha, Roland and Casio spec pages; the P-125 is discontinued and listed for used buyers.
| Yamaha MODX M8 | Roland FP-90X | Casio Privia PX-S3100 | Yamaha P-125 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Type | Performance synthesizer | Portable digital piano | Slim digital piano | Portable digital piano (discontinued) |
| Action | GHS weighted | PHA-50 wood/plastic hybrid, escapement | Smart Scaled Hammer Action | GHS weighted |
| Sound engine | AWM2 + FM-X + AN-X | Pure Acoustic Piano Modeling | Multi-dimensional Morphing AiR | Pure CF sampling |
| Sounds | 3,487 Performances | 362 tones | 700 tones | 24 voices |
| Built-in speakers | None | 25 W x 2 + 5 W x 2 | 8 W + 8 W | 7 W x 2 |
| Weight | 29 lb 15 oz (13.6 kg) | 52 lb 1 oz with music rest | 11.4 kg (25.1 lb) | See used listing |
| Battery power | No | No | Yes, 6 x AA | No |
| Status | Current | Current | Current | Discontinued; successor P-225 |
| Scott's take | Hands-on (plays it weekly) | Research-based | Research-based | Research-based |
Bottom line
- Need organ, synth and layered sounds every night: MODX M8.
- Piano feel and built-in speakers matter most: FP-90X.
- Lightest carry or battery power: PX-S3100.
- Cheap used backup: P-125, or the P-225 if buying new.
Labels: Only the MODX M8 is hands-on; the other three columns are research-based. Specs are from the manufacturer pages cited on each product page. Prices change, so use the "Check price" buttons on each product page.
Where to buy
Yamaha MODX M8
88-key GHS weighted performance synthesizer with AWM2, FM-X and AN-X engines. The board Scott plays on stage every week.
Roland FP-90X
Roland's flagship portable digital piano: modeled piano engine, PHA-50 wood-hybrid keys and a four-speaker system.
Casio Privia PX-S3100
Slim 88-key digital piano, about 25 lb, with 700 tones, built-in speakers and optional battery power.
Yamaha P-125 (discontinued)
Portable 88-key digital piano with speakers. Discontinued; Yamaha's current successor is the P-225.